Sony ICD-B5 Digital Voice Recorder

In all of the above cases, I could not hear student questions unless the students were sitting right next to me.

I hope this helps people make a decision in purchasing a digital recorder.


For the price, it serves it's purpose.   January 18, 2003
 10 out of 10 found this review helpful

.... Sound quality: not much better than a microcassette in the same price range. Size and weight: very light and compact. Recording time: up to 150 minutes. High and low mic sensitivity.
Now, being a realistic person, I did not expect crystal clarity. I DID expect a unit that was light and small enough to carry in a shirt pocket, and one that was convenient to operate. I have used the unit for recording meetings (high sensitivity), and for dictating ideas when they occur to me. For these purposes, the unit works very well. Having realistic expectations, I am quite satisfied with the recorder. If one wants better sound quality and the ability to download to a computer, expect to pay for these features; I've done some research, and you can expect to pay $150.00 and up for such a unit.
Perhaps some see the word "digital" and ideas of crystal-clean audio come to mind. Having recorded in studios both in analog and digitally for many years, I certainly didn't expect high frequency noise supression in a tiny unit costing fifty bucks!
The convenience of an inexpensive unit such as the ICD-B5 is surprisingly small size and weight, pretty incredible recording lengths, and saying goodbye to the inconvenience and cost of microcassettes. Being able to essentially overdub a recording comes in quite handy at times, as does being able to locate files quickly (no fast forward - reverse frustrations).
I write music and fiction. I wanted a device that I could easily record thoughts and ideas before they were gone forever. I got what I paid for, and I'm quite happy with it.
If you expect more, expect to pay for. This is pocket-size consumer electronics for fifty bucks, folks. For what it is and was designed for - and with realistic expectations - it's not a bad deal.


Good for basic use   January 17, 2003
 10 out of 10 found this review helpful

I work for three magazines and use this recorder for professional, demanding work. Before purchasing the Sony ICD-B5, I shopped around quite a bit and heard good things about this particular recorder (Consumer Reports, etc.). Although the reviews were accurate in their positive points, unfortunately, only people needing just the basics should think about purchasing this product.

There are a few major things that Sony -- and other manufacturers of these recorders -- need to take into consideration (honestly, I haven't really found the ideal solution for my needs).

The Sony ICD-B5 is lacking in the following areas:

* No "slow play" feature which many microcassette recorders sport. You have a choice of "Play" or "Stop"/"Pause"... that's it.

* Due to the fact that you have no "slow play," you are constantly having to hit "Pause" during playback (if you're taking notes), which wastes a lot of time and [uses] through the batteries VERY quickly. An hour and a half to two hours of interviews, including playback, and the batteries are [gone].

* The recorder has a jack that's labeled "Plug-In Power" but no one, including Sony, sells the power adapter needed.

* If you're careless and accidentally tap the "Rewind" button twice, it takes you back to the very beginning of the recording. VERY ANNOYING. Then you have to fast forward back to where you were. More time and batteries wasted. They should have a button that will take you back to the last spot in the recording that you were listening.

* Slow fast forward and rewind -- I expected something tremendously better for digital. Unfortunately, these two functions act just like they do on a microcassette. Slow and tedious.

I gave this item 3 stars because, honestly, the other digital recorders I've seen don't seem to be that much better.


You get what you pay for!   January 11, 2003
 5 out of 5 found this review helpful

Summary: despite lack of certain potentially important features, this unit gets the job done for a great price.

...Previous reviewers have a good point about the sound quality being sub-par. I certainly wouldn't dare try to record music with it. However, it is *more* than adequate for voice notes and relatively close-range voice recording.

I tried to record a class lecture with it from my seat at the back of the room and the results were not that great. I'm sure that if I would have set it near the professor, it would have come out just fine....

This unit does not have VOX (voice-operated recording, to save space and battery life when recording lectures or meetings). Personally, I'll live without this, as I don't think I'd be able to fill up the whole 2.5 hours in a day and I'm using rechargeable batteries. ...

There are some great Sony features like the ability to split up (index) a single recording and the ability to do the reverse, join two messages together. Also, the unit allows you to go back to a message (say, message 31 of 55) and add more to it's end. This is really nice in case you need it, which if you are keeping reminders to yourself, you probably will.

The folders feature is nice, as well. Though there are only two of them, as compared to other, more expensive units which have five or more, they're good enough for me.

I...I realized that if I wanted to archive my voice recordings, all I'd need to do is stick a standard minijack cable between the unit's headphone output and my computer's soundcard, open up a sound recording program and hit "record." Of course, the sound quality won't be quite as good as the actual file in the unit itself, but then again we're not talking about DVD-Audio-quality sound here, anyways.

In all, this is a great unit. Yes, the whole thing feels a touch flimsy, but this also contributes to it's pleasant *lack* of weight. A great buy on a great unit.


This Thing is QUALITY!!!!!!   January 7, 2003
 1 out of 1 found this review helpful

This is a very quality little guy
for example, it can record the following things:

Physics Class lectures
Lee Corso
Playstation 2 sound clips

and how in the name of the Lord our God can you lose a button??
Jeez Louize!! - Great Product Buddies!!!!!11